Thursday, November 12, 2009

Will There be Appetite for Another Stimulus Plan?

Calculated Risk has a nice post detailing the Possible Upside Surprises, Downside Risks going forward. One area [frequently] mentioned is that only 1/3 of the fiscal stimulus has been spent to date. Below are the details how the ~$180 billion fiscal stimulus has been spent.

But while the impact of the stimulus has been HUGE (Mark Zandi, Chief Economist of Moody's estimates the stimulus contributed ~3% to Q2 '09 GDP and 3.5% to Q3 '09 GDP before the Joint Economic Committee), much of the impact is now fading (a vast amount of the impact was due to pulling demand forward). Calculated Risk details the potential drag and the why there may be appetite for an additional stimulus plan in 2010:

This suggests that all the growth in Q3 was due to the stimulus package, and the impact will now wane - only 2% in Q4, and 1.5% in Q1 2010 - and then the package will be a drag on the economy in the 2nd half of 2010.

With unemployment above 10%, there will be significant political pressure for another stimulus package - especially if the economy starts to slow in the first half of 2010. This next package could be several hundred billion (maybe $500 billion) and could increase GDP growth in 2010 above my forecast.
Source: Mark Zandi


  1. A note on the headline: There's no "Their" There

  2. 1. On 4 December 09 Krugman states: "The stimulus has already had its maximum impact on growth..." and I'm wondering why he says it, until I read your post above. Thanks for the clarity.

    2. If you have a half full bucket that leaks, you can use a hose to keep the bucket half full, or you can try to fill it more. On your eye candy above, the green, the yellow, and the purple all serve only to keep the bucket half full: Maintenance. Only the little blue bit on the bottom is an effort to fill the bucket more. Only the little blue bit is stimulus.