Showing posts with label bailout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bailout. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Time to Pat Myself on the Back...

Bloomberg reports the TARP bailout actually made money:

The U.S. government’s bailout of financial firms through the Troubled Asset Relief Program provided taxpayers with higher returns than yields paid on 30- year Treasury bonds -- enough money to fund the Securities and Exchange Commission for the next two decades.

The government has earned $25.2 billion on its investment of $309 billion in banks and insurance companies, an 8.2 percent return over two years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. That beat U.S. Treasuries, high-yield savings accounts, money- market funds and certificates of deposit.

Back in an October 2nd, 2008 post titled Bailout Can Work and at No Cost to Taxpayers I concluded:
The bailout will not solve all the economic problems we are currently facing. In fact, not even close. We still have a massive amount of leverage in the system that needs to be unwound. However, if this bailout is done right, it should help unfreeze credit markets (which are currently non-functioning) at little or no cost to taxpayers.
More here and back to normal broadcasting (I promise)...

Monday, June 7, 2010

The Too Big to Fail... Fail

The Big Picture details the huge issue with bailouts of the largest financial institutions:

One of the most compelling factors was the horrific impact past bailouts have had on other competitors in the sector. Bailouts rewarded the worst managements, the least deserving shareholders, and the most reckless creditors. (That’s not how capitalism is supposed to work).

As it turns out, the banking sector is no different than these other industries that have been bailed out. After the government’s largesse, bad companies do well — and at the expense of the well managed, responsible, non-reckless firms.

Forbes with the figures:

Thanks to government subsidies ranging from a steep yield curve to bailout funds (bold mine):

Six giant banks made $51 billion (including the loss by Citi) in profits last year, while the rest of the banking industry — the other 980 banking institutions — all lost money (in aggregate).

Source: Forbes

Monday, May 17, 2010

France and the PIIGS

Apparently French President Nicolas Sarkozy threatened to pull France off of the euro, which helped push the 750 billion euro intervention through. But, Ex-SKF provides some numbers that support the theory that Sarkozy was most certainly bluffing (recreated below in chart form).



Ex-SKF reasons:

Merkel probably relented because she didn't want to be accused of breaking up the eurozone and endangering the EU collapse. She should know better, as France cannot possibly afford to go it alone. She should have called Sarkozy's bluff.
Source: NY Times

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

TARP Turns One

CNN Money details:

Taxpayers stand to lose between $100 billion and $200 billion on TARP -- Treasury's $700 billion financial market bailout.

While that's nothing to sneeze at, many experts say that the Troubled Asset Relief Program helped rescue the economy from a second Great Depression.

But there are others who argue that the billions of dollars that taxpayers shelled out simply delayed an inevitable epic collapse of the financial sector.

A year ago, when the financial markets were in turmoil, the Bush administration and supporters in Congress said TARP would be used to buy banks' troubled assets, and would be an investment -- it could even turn a profit.

But TARP, which celebrates its first birthday on Oct. 3, has been used for many programs it was not initially intended for, like saving AIG, automakers and helping struggling homeowners.


Source: Ritholtz

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

D.C. Hates Cash for Clunkers

Floyd Norris reports:

Where were all those clunkers that the government paid to get rid of?

A disproportionate number were in New England. The South seems to have not had its share.

The government released the state-by-state figures today for the clunker rebates. Using the latest population estimates from the Census Department, I calculated the per capita dollars sent out by this program to residents of each state.

Leading the pack is New Hampshire, which stands to receive $17.51 a person. Vermont is second at $15.90. Rounding out the top 10 are Minnesota, North Dakota, Maryland, Michigan, South Dakota, Delaware, Virginia and Maine.

The least money went to residents of the District of Columbia, at 11 cents each. That means the average New Hampshire resident received 159 times as much money as the average District denizen. D.C. residents filed for just $67,500 in all. Since the clunker rebates were as much as $4,500 a car, that could translate into just 15 cars.
Click for ginormous chart


Source: DOT

Thursday, August 6, 2009

AIG Soars... Still Down 96% Year over Year

WSJ details:

Have the markets gone mad?

AIG closed up 63% to $22. Yes, AIG.

The troubled insurance giant — which reports earnings Friday — announced earlier this week that it company would soon get a new CEO. But that was on Monday, and wouldn’t really explain today’s surge.

Speaking to MarketWatch, Miller Tabak analyst Peter Bookvar says that he sees a technical issue at work stemming from the company’s recent reverse stock split. “It’s another example of where the float has dramatically shrunk, and now there’s a massive short squeeze going on,” Bookvar said. “There is certainly no news to account for it (AIG’s stock move), he added.

First a little perspective. Even after yesterday's 60% jump, AIG's share price is down an astounding 96% year over year (and down 35% from levels seen just 2 months ago).


While something does seem fishy, this type of volaility for AIG shouldn't be all that unexpected. After all, AIG is no ordinary stock. It is just a binary option on the continued bailing out of an entity currently too big too fail. At the end of the day, AIG should be worth $0.00 (i.e. nothing) or a high multiple of its current valuation.

The reason being it is a non-zero probability that the government will hand over billions more to equity investors via subsidized financing of their operations for years to come. How do you model that?

Source: Yahoo

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

It Pays to Lobby

FireDogLake reports:

An FDL review of lobbying reports for the first quarter of 2009 reveals that banks receiving federal bailout funds spent over $13 million lobbying against consumer interests and for the financial benefit of their executives.

In the first quarter of 2009, banks such as Bank of America, JP Morgan and Wells Fargo that received billions in taxpayer assistance focused their lobbying efforts on defeating attempts to regulate credit card practices, specifically caps on interest rates. They also lobbied extensively to prevent legislation that would have allowed bankruptcy judges to write down mortgage principle ("cramdown"), which FDL examined yesterday. At the same time, they lobbied on behalf of their executives to be paid without limit.
Below is a chart of bailout funds received as a multiple of that $13mm spent on lobbying in the quarter.



Don't feel too bad for Credit Suisse... while the lowest "multiple", that $580k still got them $400mm. Not too shabby.

Monday, March 30, 2009

TARP Running Dry

First the WSJ details:

The U.S. Treasury Department said it expects to have about $134.5 billion left in its financial-rescue fund, giving the Obama administration a cushion as it implements a range of expensive programs aimed at unlocking the credit market and boosting ailing industries.
If you think $134.5 billion left sounds like the well is running dry, then take a look at what Keith Hennessey (former director of the National Economic Council) believes that figure is closer to:
When President Obama took office, $387 B of the $700 B of available TARP funds had already been publicly committed. Here’s the breakdown.

This meant that the Obama team had $313 B left to commit before reaching the $700 B limit.
Since January 20th, Keith estimates that the Obama administration has committed as much as an additional $280.



If this is correct, we have less than $35 billion remaining in the TARP. Back to Keith:
Uh-oh.

There’s some uncertainty around the $80 B figure to further expand TALF, because the Administration has been ambiguous about how big the new TALF would be in total. I’ll bet they’re scrambling this week trying to figure out what they actually meant.

They can create some wiggle room for themselves if they say that the $15 B for small businesses and the $5 B for auto parts suppliers are a subset of the $100 B (in total) for “consumer credit.” This uncertainty and ambiguity should not obscure the critical point: they’re almost out of money.

Monday, March 16, 2009

The AIG Public Relations Fiasco Continues: Bonuses and Backdoor Bailouts

This Saturday, Marketwatch reported:

In a letter to Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, AIG Chief Executive Edward Liddy said that AIG had committed to paying the bonuses to employees of the financial-products unit and that the payments were "binding obligations," the Journal reported.

The $450 million in bonuses are over and above $121.5 million of incentive payments for 2008 that AIG will make to about 6,400 of its employees. And AIG is laying out another $600 million in retention payments to more than 4,000 employees, the Journal reported.

Liddy told Geithner that he did not like the $450 million bonus arrangement but that outside counsel had advised the company that it must go through with it, the Journal reported.
More specifically, the $450 Billion in bonuses were focused on employees in the unit that lost $40.5 Billion in 2008. Not sure what is in place that guarantees these bonuses, but why not withhold these bonuses and make AIG fight tooth and nail through the legal system for the money?

The sad thing is... the above is nothing compared to the latest and greatest PR fiasco from AIG. As a little background, last weekend the WSJ detailed bailout funds were being diverted "backdoor to the banks":
The beneficiaries of the government’s bailout of American International Group Inc. include at least two dozen U.S. and foreign financial institutions that have been paid roughly $50 billion since the Federal Reserve first extended aid to the insurance giant.

Among those institutions are Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Germany’s Deutsche Bank AG, each of which received roughly $6 billion in payments between mid-September and December 2008, according to a confidential document and people familiar with the matter.

Other banks that received large payouts from AIG late last year include Merrill Lynch, now part of Bank of America Corp., and French bank Société Générale SA.

More than a dozen firms with smaller exposures to AIG also received payouts, including Morgan Stanley, Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC and HSBC Holdings PLC, according to the confidential document.
Forget $50 Billion... late last night AIG has released the following (the FT reports):
AIG paid out $22.4bn of collateral related to credit default swaps, $27.1bn to help cancel swaps and another $43.7bn to satisfy the obligations of its securities lending operation. The payments were made between September 16 and the end of last year.

Goldman Sachs, which has also accepted US government support, received payments worth $12.9bn. Three European banks – France’s Société Générale, Germany’s Deutsche Bank and the UK’s Barclays – were paid the next-largest amounts. SocGen received $11.9bn; Deutsche $11.8bn; and Barclays $7.9bn.
Please note that Felix at Market Movers makes the case that it may not be exactly as bad as first thought... I'll follow up with details if they come out.


Look... I understand the importance of preventing systemic failure (i.e. a Lehman fiasco), but clearly communicating where the money is going (in real-time), why it is going there, and doling it out in a fair and objective manner is the only way the people of the United States will accept (without force) the injection of trillions of dollars back into the financial system. I concede that fair is relative, but when you try to secretly move $80+ Billion into the financial system in a backdoor manner, you lose trust which is REQUIRED in this environment.

Specifically, I have the following problems with the above mentioned backdoor bailout (drum roll please).....
  1. We were told AIG was bailed out due their importance to the system. Not to bail out supposed "solvent" institutions (with taxpayer money indeed going directly towards "solvent" institutions, why isn't the taxpayer receiving at least an additional equity stake)

  2. The moral hazard associated with bailing out "counter-party risk" (i.e. IT WAS PRICED TOO LOW) only makes it more likely that counter-party risk will once again be under-priced AGAIN in the future (hell, if the government is willing to step in, why do the credit work?)

  3. As Yves from Naked Capitalism pointed out, Goldman Sachs was bailed out to the tune of $12 billion (via AIG), but Goldman "had a seat at the table during the AIG rescue talks". How is this possible? That would be like a homeowner, that has failed to make their home payments, joining the board of a mortgage servicer and cramming down his own loan. Would that possibly ever happen?

  4. U.S. taxpayer money was used to bailout non-US institutions! Again, in return for a 0% equity stake in any of these firms!
In fact, three of the top four AND eight of the top eleven beneficiaries by amount received above, were non-US institutions.

Source: AIG

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Tic... Tic... Tic...

As everyone knows by now, AIG lost $61.7 Billion last quarter. That's $7757 per second...



Reader Nitric Oxide points out:

You stop at 3 tics, if you extend your graph to show a few more tics the effect would be much higher. The scary effect, that is.


Here's 30 second worth... or $233,000.

Source: Dealbook

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

The Case for Nationalization?

The NY Times reports Geithner's plan prevailed. As Mish comments:

Notice how insane this is. The market cap of Citigroup(C), JP Morgan Chase(JPM), and Bank of America (BAC) combined is $158 billion, yet the program is going to provide an initial $250 billion to $500 billion (with more insanity coming) just to deal with "soured mortgage-related assets".


I'll add in Wells Fargo (WFC) to make his point even more clear. In addition, it is important to note that the equity only has this value based on the assumption they were going to be bailed out.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Game Theory: Why Giving the "Option" to Limit Pay Won't Work

The AP reports:

The Obama administration plans to limit pay to $500,000 a year for executives of government-assisted financial institutions in a new get-tough approach to bankers and Wall Street, a senior administration official said Tuesday.
Back in September I used the below chart to show why giving banks the option to accepting TARP money with the caveat that they must limit pay will fail (they key is the option). My guess... if this passes, many banks will simply give the bailout money back (hey, maybe that's what the Whitehouse is hoping for).

Originally posted September 26th, 2008:

Lets assume for the time being that there are only two banks; Bank A and Bank B.

The media / political pundits would have you believe the likely outcome of the bailout is the top-left box in which both Bank A and B sell risk assets to the Treasury. In this case, the result is a more regulated banking industry, with imposed limits to salary, but importantly markets clear.

Click for larger table:



HOWEVER, it is in BOTH banks interest to deviate from that.

Why? Simple. If Bank A (or B) believe the other is selling their risk assets to the Treasury; they will each be better off holding on to theirs.

Why? If the other bank sells and they hold, markets will still clear (in theory) and the bank that holds onto their risk assets can sell at the new market prices. This results in increased market share as they:
  • Can pay more for talent
  • Are less regulated
  • Don’t have the stigma of selling to the Treasury (think of what selling portrays to the market)
This is even worse in the “real world” as all banks have the incentive to wait for other banks to sell risk assets to the Treasury to clear markets.

The likely result? The bottom right box in which no bank sells voluntarily and markets remain frozen. While there were many problems with the initial plan, at least there was a 100% incentive to sell the assets.

Friday, January 16, 2009

First Third of TARP Could Cost Taxpayers $64 Billion (i.e. a 26% Loss)

WSJ reports:

CBO said the $64 billion figure generally represents the difference between what Treasury paid for the investments or lent to firms and the market value of the transactions. This difference, called the “subsidy rate”, was 26% for the first third of the TARP funds.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Stimulus Projected to Save 3.675mm Jobs... 3mm Too Little?

Christina Romer and Jared Bernstein have released projected jobs created / saved due to the Obama stimulus plan... a cool 3.675 million. The charts below show where these jobs are projected to come, by sector and by method (i.e. direct or indirect).

The most jobs, not surprisingly, are in construction. Other top sectors include retail (from stimulating consumption), leisure (gotta do something when laid off right?), and manufacturing.

Table 2:



How? Well, the majority are expected to be indirectly created not from the plan itself, but by the recycling of dollars / demand created from those created directly. Projections are for state relief (i.e. fund projects that would otherwise be cut) to save / create the most, followed by the protection of those jobs vulnerable in the downturn, and tax cuts.

Table 5:



The question is obvious... is this enough? According to Christina Romer and Jared Bernstein's "R/B" own conclusion:

  • The recovery plan needs to be large to counter the tremendous job loss that is likely to occur
So is it? Paul Krugman says it clearly is not:
Here’s one way to look at it: R/B show the effects of the plan rapidly fading out during 2011. Yet at the end of 2011 the unemployment rate is still 6.3%. Meanwhile, the CBO estimates the natural rate, aka “full employment,” at just 4.8%. Why does the plan go away with the job undone?
In other words, R/B and Paul all conclude that the plan needs to be large enough to offset the jobs lost, but R/B themselves project that it won't. By their own analysis, employment is expected to rise to 9% with no stimulus. Comparing employment figures from December 2007 (unemployment at that time was 4.8%, which equals the CBO "full employment" level) with the projected employment figures for 2010 using R/B's 9% unemployment figure, I project the those unemployed to rise 6.7mm from December 2007. This is 3mm higher than the number of jobs the stimulus plan is projected to create / save (the difference between the loss in employment and gain in unemployment is the population growth) or to be blunt, not enough.


Monday, December 22, 2008

Is the Bailout Hurting Pension Plans?

Interesting post over at the Peterson Institute by Jacob Funk Kirkegaard from last month (he nailed it) with the secondary effects of the bailouts / flooding of liquidity into the system on corporations pension plans and balance sheets:

As the financial crisis deepens, the world’s central banks and financial authorities have gained broad support for their efforts to reintroduce liquidity to the credit markets, get banks to lend again and bring down spreads and bond yields. But these sensible and indeed required steps to avoid a repeat of the 1930s may come with a drawback: a rapid decline in corporate bond yields, which threaten to produce rapidly rising funding shortfalls in defined benefit (DB) pension funds.
The reason is that the present value of these pension liabilities are discounted at roughly the yield of a AA Corporate bond. While markets sold off this year hurting plans, the plans did benefit from a higher AA Corporate rate (spreads widened significantly), which reduced the present value of their liabilities (i.e. future benefit payments).

Looking below at the 10 year AA bond yield over the past year, along with the present value for paying $1 million per year over the next 30 years at this rate (this is obviously a simplified version of the "real world") we can see that the cost of liabilities has bounced back significantly (~20%) over the past few months. In other words, corporations reporting with a 12/31 year end vs. a 9/30 year end will show two very different sets of liabilities, which directly impacts their balance sheet.



Back to Jacob:
In today’s financial crisis, US corporations and state and local governments with a DB pension plan have so far been hit in different ways. The large recent declines in global stock markets have hit pension plan asset valuations hard, and without doubt the Pension Protection Act (PPA) of 2006 (for corporations) as well as the gradual introduction of accrual accounting methods for state and local government pension funds by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) will require future increases in pension plan sponsors’ pension contribution levels.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Multiplier Math: Is U.S. Protectionism on the Way?

We detailed in a prior post how large a stimulus package would need to be based on certain assumptions in unemployment and the multiplier (a summary chart of that discussion is as follows):



As can be seen above, if unemployment were to rise above current 8.5% estimates, the multiplier becomes increasingly important in determining an appropriate size for a stimulus package. Thus, an important question is how large will the multiplier be?

Fortunately, Dani Rodrick's recent post dives into the math behind the multiplier and he isn't fond of what it tells him.

First, the multiplier:



In other words, the three ways to increase the multiplier is to:

  • Increase the rate of consumption (hence the public works projects, rather than rebate checks which went right to savings first pass)
  • Decrease the tax rate (for this reason, I expect the Obama administration to put tax hikes on hold)
  • Decrease imports (thus, more production within the U.S. is needed to satisfy any given level of demand)
Dani seems to believe the third (i.e. decreasing imports) would be rather easy. In an example he calculates a multiplier of 1.8 based on MPC of .8, MTR of .2, and MPI of .2, which is increased more than 50% in his example through the raising of import tariffs:
It is pretty easy to increase the multiplier; just raise import tariffs by enough so that the marginal propensity to import out of income is reduced substantially (to zero if you want the multiplier to go all the way to 2.8). Yes, yes, import protection is inefficient and not a very neighborly thing to do--but should we really care if the alternative is significantly lower growth and higher unemployment? More to the point, will Obama and his advisers care?
With unemployment at 10%, a difference in the marginal propensity of imports can mean the difference of hundreds of billions of dollars in stimulus. In other words:
unless we come up with a solution to the credit constraints in the developing world, we are going to either endanger the effectiveness of Keynesian policies in the U.S. and other advanced nations, or risk a sharp increase in protectionism. Not a pleasant choice.

Thursday, December 4, 2008

Pledges to Date Redux

JJStein asks for it, JJStein gets it... WWII's inflation adjusted cost added to the 'Chart of the Week':



For a breakdown of those pledges, go here.

Source: Ritholtz.com

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

Relative Size of Pledges... Part III

This is the last relative comparison I'll make of the pledges to date... for now. Below is a chart of some interesting analysis posted at Riholtz.com from Jim Bianco detailing past "big budget" government expenditures:

These massive expenditures pale in comparison to the current pledges made by the Fed, FDIC, Treasury, and FHA to date (again pledges, not costs).

Hey, I'd rather bail out banks than have another war, but a trip to Mars would have been awfully exciting.

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Pledges by Fed, FDIC, Treasury, and FHA = $90k per Taxpayer

We noted earlier the absolute size of this, but assuming 90 million taxpayers (there were ~86 million that actually paid taxes in 2004), max pledges made by the Fed, FDIC, Treasury, and FHA to date amount to ~$90,000 per taxpayer (or ~$30,000 per U.S. citizen).



Not that I don't believe it's needed, but this puts it all in a little perspective.

Bailout Pledges More than $8 Trillion

Hot off the press, Part I. Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility at $200B. Details per the WSJ:

Under the TALF, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY) will lend up to $200 billion on a non-recourse basis to holders of certain AAA-rated ABS backed by newly and recently originated consumer and small business loans.
Part II. The Fed to purchase up to $600 Billion in Mortgage Backed Securities (per the AP).

The Fed says it will purchase up to $100 billion in direct obligations from mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as well as the Federal Home Loan Banks. It also will purchase another $500 billion in mortgage-backed securities, pools of mortgages that are bundled together and sold to investors.


This pushes the bailout "pledged" to date to over $8 Trillion. I understand it is NOT likely that all of these pledges made to date will be spent, but who thinks this is the last of them? Not me...

Source: Mish